The Truth About Luck: Finding the Balance Between Effort and Chance

A friend and I had a disagreement yesterday about the concept of luck. He contended that luck is the intersection between opportunity and coincidence, while I argued that luck involves more effort than opportunity. Luck possesses a qualitative aspect. We don’t say, “He won the lottery? What good chance.” After all, you need to play to win, right? Hence, there's an element of effort even in situations like the lottery, albeit minimal.

Are you a lucky or unlucky person? Many can answer this question lickety-split. And many, like my friend, will say, “That’s dumb.”

Luck is the Intersection Between Effort and Chance.

There are a lot of reasons to eschew luck. Firstly, it seems superstitious. For many, the idea of wearing a lucky pair of underwear to ensure a team's victory sounds silly. Moreover, believing in luck can sometimes provide an excuse for avoiding substantial effort. For instance, an individual who perceives themselves as unlucky might refrain from trying out for a team, reasoning, “Why bother? I won’t make it anyway. I never do.”

For those who have endured trauma or experienced prolonged adversity, excessive belief in luck can lead to a decrease in self-efficacy. Such individuals might convince themselves that they lack the ability to effect change in their lives and, even worse, may feel deserving of painful circumstances.

Conversely, relying too little on chance can cause undue anxiety. Consider the college admissions process. High school students contort themselves into every conceivable shape to fit into the boxes that schools insist they check. However, despite deserving reward for their accomplishments, only a select few will be chosen. Failing to acknowledge the chance factor beyond one's control puts undue pressure on performance and leads to self-deprecation when expectations are not met.

Believing that you have either too little or too much control can lead to trouble. For many, reconsidering luck and embracing what we don’t control as a matter of chance is a step in the right direction.

Moreover, finding the balance between effort and chance can help minimize anxiety and enhance the likelihood of success. This necessitates ongoing assessment of your ventures. Playing the lottery involves minimal effort and a large element of chance. Conversely, trying out for a team will likely benefit from significant effort, coupled with an awareness of chance to temper expectations and potential disappointment. Even with unwavering dedication, you may not be selected. Thus, it's essential to map out the intersection of effort and chance for your endeavors, ensuring your road to success is navigated with realistic expectations.

TO READ MORE, SUBSCRIBE TO MY SUBSTACK